USA: Supreme Court Considering Whether Idaho Abortion Ban Supersedes Federal Emergency Care Requirement

by Karen Faulkner, Worthy News Correspondent

(Worthy News) – The US Supreme Court is considering whether a near-total ban on abortion passed by the state of Idaho has precedence over a federal law that requires that doctors provide patients with medical care – that might include an abortion – in emergency situations, Reuters reports.

The Court on Wednesday heard oral arguments in the state’s appeal against a lower court ruling that the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act 1986 (EMTALA) has precedence over Idaho’s abortion ban in situations of conflict.

Passed in 2020, and triggered into effect in 2022 following the Supreme Court’s reversal of Roe v Wade, Idaho’s law bans abortion in all circumstances unless the procedure is needed to prevent the woman’s death. Doctors who violate the law face 2-5 years in prison and the loss of their medical license.

EMTALA requires that hospitals covered by the federal Medicare program must “stabilize” patients with emergency medical conditions. Hospitals may face lawsuits by patients who do not receive the care they need.

Questions raised by the justices during oral arguments indicated no consensus has yet been reached. “Within rare cases, there’s a significant number where the woman … her life is not in peril, but she’s going to lose her reproductive organs, she’s going to lose the ability to have children in the future unless an abortion takes place,” Democratic-appointee Justice Elena Kagan noted.

Conservative Justice Samuel Alito countered that EMTALA requires the “unborn child” to be given stabilizing care. “Performing an abortion is antithetical to that duty,” Alito said.

Copyright 1999-2024 Worthy News. This article was originally published on Worthy News and was reproduced with permission.


Latest News from Worthy News

Extending Trump Tax Cuts Would Add $4 Trillion To Deficit, CBO Says
Extending Trump Tax Cuts Would Add $4 Trillion To Deficit, CBO Says

New projections show that extending provisions of President Donald Trump’s 2017 tax cut past their sunset dates would add $4 trillion to the federal deficit over the next decade.

Israel In Eurovision Final Despite Massive Anti-Israel Protests
Israel In Eurovision Final Despite Massive Anti-Israel Protests

Europe voted to have Israel in the grand final of the world’s largest song contest in a setback for anti-Israel protesters. Israel’s 20-year-old Eden Golan impressed millions of viewers with her song “Hurricane.”

Israel’s Premier Encourages Eurovision Contestant Faces With Protests
Israel’s Premier Encourages Eurovision Contestant Faces With Protests

Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu encouraged Israeli artist Eden Golan ahead of the second semifinal of Eurovision, the world’s largest televised song contest, after she was booed and faced with massive anti-Israel protests.

Fierce Ukrainian-Russian Clashes as Moscow Warns West About Nuclear Capabilities  (Worthy News Radio)
Fierce Ukrainian-Russian Clashes as Moscow Warns West About Nuclear Capabilities (Worthy News Radio)

Russian President Vladimir Putin has accused the West of risking a global armed conflict and warned that no one would be allowed to threaten the world’s most significant nuclear power. He made the comments as Russia marked the Soviet Union’s victory over Nazi Germany in World War Two, while outside Moscow fighting continued between Russia and Ukraine.

Defense Minister: Israel Could Face a “Hot Summer” of War in the North
Defense Minister: Israel Could Face a “Hot Summer” of War in the North

Israel’s Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said Wednesday that Israelis may be facing a “hot summer” as – amid Hamas’ ongoing war against the Jewish state in Gaza – the Hezbollah Lebanese Islamic terror group has stepped up its attacks against Israel in the north, Ynet News reports.

Music Ministry Sees Over 34,000 Professions Of Faith In Christ, “Gen Z Is On Fire”
Music Ministry Sees Over 34,000 Professions Of Faith In Christ, “Gen Z Is On Fire”

The major US music ministry Winter Jam has seen over 34,000 professions of faith in Christ from young people in America this year alone, Christian Headlines (CH) reports.

USA: Pastor Says God Protected Him From Gunman Whose Firearm Jammed In Church Service
USA: Pastor Says God Protected Him From Gunman Whose Firearm Jammed In Church Service

Pennsylvania pastor Rev. Glenn Germany attests it was a “miracle of God” that the loaded gun aimed at him by Bernard Polite during a church service on Sunday would not fire because it was jammed, Christian Headlines (CH) reports.